top of page

Does Your Owners’ Agreement Still Match How You Run the Business?

23 hours ago
3 min read

Most co-owners sign their agreement at the very beginning, when everyone is excited and the roles seem obvious. Imagine two friends who start a side business together, working on it nights and weekends while keeping their full-time jobs. They split the work and the profits equally, and their operating agreement or shareholders’ agreement says so.



Take 15 minutes each year to review your ownership agreements to make sure you are aligned
Take 15 minutes each year to review your ownership agreements to make sure you are aligned

Five years later, the side business has become a real business. One owner quit her job to run it and now works sixty hours a week. The other kept his day job and helps out on Saturdays. They still split the profits equally, because that is what the agreement says. Nobody has said anything yet, but resentment is building.


This situation is common, and it is almost always preventable.


Your Agreement Describes the Day You Signed It

An owners’ agreement is a snapshot. It reflects what each person contributed and expected to do when the business started. It does not update itself when someone’s role changes, when one owner puts in more money, or when a family situation changes how much time someone can give. Even a carefully drafted agreement can only reflect what the owners knew at the time.


If your agreement does not say how working owners are paid, North Carolina law fills the gap, and the default rules do not ask who is doing the work. For an LLC, the North Carolina Limited Liability Company Act divides distributions in proportion to what each owner contributed unless the owners agree otherwise. For a corporation, dividends follow share ownership.


The Conversation You Are Avoiding

The hard part is rarely the document itself. The hard part is raising the subject when the relationship already feels strained. The agreement gives you a neutral place to start. It is easier to say “our agreement no longer fits how we work” than to say “I am doing more than you are.”


Before you sit down together, think through a few questions. Who is working in the business now, and how much? Should an owner who works in the business be paid for that work before profits are divided? Should ownership percentages stay the same, or has someone earned a larger share? Who has authority to make day-to-day decisions, and which decisions still need every owner’s agreement?


You do not have to change everything. Many co-owners keep their equal ownership and simply add compensation for the owner who runs the business. That one change can resolve most of the tension.


In this example, the owners might agree that the owner running the business receives a set monthly payment for her work, and that whatever profit remains is still split equally. The other owner keeps the ownership stake he paid for, and the owner doing the work is paid fairly for her time.


Put the New Arrangement in Writing

A verbal agreement to pay one owner more is better than nothing, but it leaves too much room for memories to differ later. Once you agree, amend your operating agreement or shareholders’ agreement, or adopt a written resolution, so the new terms become part of the business’s records. Follow whatever amendment process your current agreement requires, such as unanimous written consent. The amendment should also say what happens if roles change again. For example, it might state that the payment ends if the working owner steps back, or that the owners will revisit the arrangement every year.


How owners are paid also has tax consequences. Payments to an LLC member and salary paid to a shareholder are treated differently, and an S corporation election changes the picture again. Bring your accountant into the conversation before you finalize anything.


Make the Review a Routine

The best time to revisit an owners’ agreement is before anyone feels shortchanged. A good habit is to read it once a year, perhaps when you meet with your accountant to plan for taxes. You should also review it whenever something significant changes, such as a new owner, a major investment, or a shift in who runs daily operations. This is also a good time to review and set your company valuation for biu-out purposes.


Fifteen minutes with the agreement each year can save a friendship and a business. It also means that if something unexpected happens, the document on file reflects the business you actually have.


If your agreement no longer matches how your business runs, I can help you update it.


 

Comments


Featured Posts
Recent Posts
Archive
Search By Tags
Subscribe To and Follow Direct Talk
RSS Feed
bottom of page